The 9 Best Colored Pencils

Colored pencils have quietly become one of the most versatile art supplies available today, embraced by professional illustrators, adult coloring enthusiasts, and budding young artists alike.

Whether you are laying down smooth gradients in a detailed portrait, filling in an intricate mandala, or introducing a child to color theory for the first time, the right set makes an enormous difference in how enjoyable and rewarding the experience feels.

With hundreds of options spanning a wide range of price points, core types, pigment quality, and color counts, narrowing down the field can feel overwhelming.

This guide cuts through the noise.

Our editorial team at ProductFind researched specifications, analyzed expert review consensus from artists and instructors, and synthesized verified buyer feedback across thousands of purchases to surface the most dependable colored pencils for every skill level and budget.

From the richly pigmented wax-core performer that tops our list to budget-friendly sets that punch well above their price, our top picks are ready to browse below.

Colored Pencils Buying Guide

Choosing the right colored pencils comes down to more than picking a set with a high color count. Core composition, pigment load, paper compatibility, and even barrel diameter all shape how a pencil performs in real-world use.

The subsections below walk through every meaningful factor so you can match a set to your actual needs rather than marketing language.

If you already use other drawing media, pairing your colored pencils with quality watercolor paint sets or acrylic paint sets can open up exciting mixed-media possibilities.

Core Type: Wax-Based vs. Oil-Based

The binder holding the pigment together is arguably the single most important variable in a colored pencil.

Wax-based cores, used in sets like the Prismacolor Premier, are buttery and lay down color with minimal pressure, making them ideal for smooth blending and burnishing.

Their main drawback is wax bloom, a milky haze that can appear on heavily worked surfaces over time, though a light coat of fixative resolves it easily.

Oil-based cores, found in sets from KALOUR and Aenir, are slightly firmer. They resist wax bloom entirely and tend to layer more crisply, which artists who prefer controlled line work often appreciate.

The trade-off is that they require a bit more pressure to achieve the same saturation level as a soft wax core.

Neither type is objectively superior; the right choice depends on your drawing style and the techniques you rely on most.

Some sets marketed as “soft core” blend both binding agents to hit a middle ground. When reviewing product listings, look for explicit mention of wax-based or oil-based formulation rather than relying on “soft core” alone, since that term is applied inconsistently across brands.

Pigment Quality and Color Vibrancy

Pigment load determines how saturated and opaque a pencil appears on paper. Artist-grade pencils like the Prismacolor Premier carry a high pigment-to-binder ratio, which is why they produce rich, dense color with fewer strokes.

Student-grade and budget sets typically use more filler, requiring additional layers to achieve comparable saturation. This is not a deal-breaker for casual coloring, but it becomes significant when you are blending across large areas or aiming for photorealistic shading.

Lightfastness is a related concern that is easy to overlook. Lightfast ratings indicate how resistant a pigment is to fading under light exposure. For artwork intended to be displayed or preserved, sets with documented lightfastness ratings are strongly preferable.

Many budget sets do not publish lightfastness data at all, which is itself informative. If longevity matters to your work, prioritize sets that are transparent about their pigment sourcing.

Color Count and Range

A higher color count does not automatically mean a better set. What matters more is the breadth and balance of the palette.

A well-curated 48-count set covering a wide value range in each hue family can outperform a 120-count set that duplicates similar shades without meaningful distinction between them.

For beginners and coloring-book enthusiasts, sets in the 48 to 72 count range offer enough variety without becoming overwhelming.

Artists working on complex illustrations or portraits often gravitate toward larger sets, such as the KALOUR 180-count or PRINA 120-count, because having pre-mixed skin tones, granular value steps, and specialty metallic colors on hand reduces the amount of in-drawing mixing required.

If you are new to the medium, starting with a smaller set and adding individual pencils as your skills develop is a smarter investment than buying the largest set available from day one.

Also consider whether individual pencils can be purchased separately. With artist-grade sets you use frequently, certain colors wear down faster than others. Brands that sell open-stock replacements save you from buying a full new set just to replace one or two depleted colors.

Core Diameter and Barrel Construction

Core diameter affects both line width and breakage resistance. Thicker cores (3.8 mm and above) lay down color quickly and are more forgiving during sharpening, making them a good fit for younger users or artists who prefer bold, expressive strokes.

Thinner cores allow for finer detail work but can snap more easily inside the barrel if the pencil is dropped or sharpened aggressively.

Barrel shape is worth noting too. Round barrels roll off desks more easily but are comfortable for long sessions. Hexagonal barrels stay put on a tilted surface and are common in professional sets.

Some specialty pencils, like Crayola Twistables, eliminate the need for a sharpener altogether by using a mechanical twist-up mechanism, which is especially practical for children.

Blending and Layering Performance

Colored pencils require layering multiple strokes to build depth, and how smoothly two colors blend into each other is a key differentiator between sets.

Soft wax-core pencils blend most easily using a colorless blender pencil, a cotton swab, or even a fingertip.

Oil-based pencils blend better with a solvent such as odorless mineral spirits applied with a brush, giving artists greater control over the transition.

Verified buyer feedback consistently highlights blending performance as one of the first things users notice after switching sets.

Artists who previously used basic student-grade pencils frequently report that moving to a higher-quality soft-core set dramatically reduces the effort needed to achieve smooth gradients.

If seamless color transitions are central to your style, prioritizing blending ability over raw color count is usually the right call. For artists who also work in paint, the blending principles overlap meaningfully with techniques used in oil paint sets.

Value, Packaging, and Included Accessories

Price per pencil varies dramatically across the sets in this guide, from affordable budget options to mid-range sets that deliver near-professional performance.

A lower upfront cost is appealing, but factor in how long the pencils last before needing replacement and whether the packaging protects them adequately during storage and transport.

Tin cases, like those included with certain KALOUR sets, offer better protection than cardboard boxes and double as a workspace organizer.

Some sets include a sharpener, sketchbook, or blending tools as part of the package. For beginners, these bundles represent real added value.

For experienced artists who already own quality sharpeners and know their preferred paper, the extras matter less than the pencils themselves.

Always check whether the included sharpener is calibrated for the specific core diameter of the pencils in the set, since a mismatched sharpener is one of the leading causes of core breakage during use.

Why You Should Trust Us

ProductFind is an independent editorial platform. Every product in this guide was evaluated using a consistent, multi-source research framework.

Our team assessed each set against key criteria including core composition, pigment quality, blending performance, color range, build quality, and overall value.

Each product receives a PF Score on a 0 to 10 scale reflecting its overall standing relative to the competition within its category.

We do not conduct our own product trials; our evaluations are grounded in research, published data, expert review consensus, and verified buyer feedback.

We draw on specifications published by manufacturers, assessments from art educators and professional illustrators, and aggregated feedback from verified purchasers who have used these pencils in real creative practice.

This approach allows us to synthesize a broader, more representative picture of real-world performance than any single perspective could provide.

ProductFind may earn a commission when you purchase through links in this article. That affiliate relationship has no bearing on our rankings, scores, or recommendations.

Products are selected and ordered based on merit as determined through our research process, not on commission rates or vendor relationships. Our editorial team operates independently of our commercial partnerships.

Final Thoughts

After thoroughly researching the colored pencil landscape, a few clear standouts emerged across different needs and budgets.

Whether you are an adult coloring enthusiast, a developing artist, or shopping for a child just discovering creative expression, there is a set on this list that fits your situation.

Below are our editorial awards based on PF Score and overall research findings.

• Best Overall: Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils, 48 Count earns the top spot with the highest PF Score in this roundup. Its ultra-soft wax core, exceptional pigment load, and smooth blending behavior place it firmly in artist-grade territory at a price accessible to serious beginners and hobbyists.
• Best Mid-Range Set: KALOUR Premium Colored Pencils, 120 Colors offers an impressive breadth of hues with a soft core that performs noticeably above its price tier, making it an ideal step-up for anyone outgrowing a basic student set.
• Best for Adult Coloring Books: Aenir 72 Colors Colored Pencils pairs an oil-based core with a well-balanced 72-color palette, delivering consistent, crease-free results across the detailed fills that adult coloring pages demand.
• Best Budget Pick: Shuttle Art 80 Colored Pencils delivers the widest color count at the lowest price point in our lineup, making it an accessible entry point for casual users and students exploring the medium for the first time.
• Best for Kids: Crayola Twistables Colored Pencil Set, 50 Count removes the sharpening variable entirely with its twist-up mechanism, reducing frustration for younger users and making it a practical, mess-free choice for classrooms and home art projects.

No matter which set you choose, the best colored pencils are the ones you reach for consistently.

Starting with a quality core at the right price for your commitment level, then expanding your toolkit as your skills grow, is the approach most artists find most rewarding over time.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between wax-based and oil-based colored pencils?

Wax-based pencils use a wax binder that produces a soft, buttery stroke ideal for blending and burnishing.

Oil-based pencils use an oil binder that results in a slightly firmer core, which layers more crisply and does not develop wax bloom over time.

Both types can produce beautiful results; the best choice depends on your preferred technique and how much blending your work involves.

Are expensive colored pencils worth it for beginners?

For complete beginners, a mid-range set is usually the smarter starting point. Artist-grade pencils shine most when the user has enough foundational skill to take advantage of their superior blending and layering properties.

Starting with a quality mid-range option lets you build technique without a large upfront investment, and you can upgrade once you understand what performance qualities matter most to your work.

Sets from KALOUR and Shuttle Art represent solid mid-range choices that will not limit a developing artist.

How many colors do I actually need?

For most coloring-book enthusiasts, a set of 48 to 72 well-selected colors is more than sufficient. Larger sets become valuable when you need granular value steps, a wider range of skin tones, or specialty colors like metallics.

Rather than buying the largest set available, consider starting with a focused palette and adding individual pencils as you identify specific gaps in your color range.

What paper works best with colored pencils?

Colored pencils perform best on paper with some tooth, meaning a slightly textured surface that grips the pigment. Cold-press watercolor paper and toned drawing paper are popular among artists for this reason.

Very smooth paper can limit how many layers you can build before the surface becomes saturated.

For coloring books, the paper weight and texture are already set by the publisher, so choosing softer-core pencils that require less pressure helps avoid bleeding through thinner pages.

Can colored pencils be used alongside other art media?

Absolutely. Colored pencils layer beautifully over watercolor washes once the paper is fully dry, adding fine detail and texture that paint alone cannot achieve. They also work well as a finishing medium over light acrylic underpaintings.

Some artists use solvent blending to create effects that closely resemble paint. If you work across media, experimenting with watercolor paints as an underpainting base is a technique widely used by professional illustrators.

How do I prevent colored pencil cores from breaking during sharpening?

Core breakage during sharpening is most often caused by internal fractures from being dropped rather than a defect in the sharpener. Using a quality sharpener calibrated for the pencil’s barrel diameter makes a significant difference.

Sharpening slowly and rotating the pencil rather than forcing it forward reduces stress on the core. Storing pencils horizontally in a tin or roll case, rather than tip-down in a cup, also protects the cores from impact fractures over time.

About the author