We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more

The 8 Best Color Correctors

Dark circles, redness, or uneven pigmentation that foundation can't quite cover? A targeted color corrector neutralizes unwanted tones before you even reach for concealer.

Assorted color corrector makeup products and swatches displayed on palette
Photo by pompi

Color correctors are one of the most underrated tools in any makeup kit.

Whether you’re dealing with persistent dark circles, stubborn redness from rosacea or breakouts, or uneven hyperpigmentation that foundation alone can’t fully hide, a targeted color corrector works by using opposing hues on the color wheel to neutralize unwanted tones before you even reach for your concealer or foundation.

The right formula can mean the difference between piling on layers of coverage and achieving a genuinely natural, skin-like finish with minimal product.

This guide covers the best color correctors available right now, evaluated by the ProductFind editorial team through comprehensive research: we analyzed manufacturer specifications, cross-referenced expert review consensus from professional makeup artists and beauty editors, and weighed verified buyer feedback across thousands of real-world purchases.

Options from Stila, Charlotte Tilbury, Bobbi Brown, L.A. Girl, Catrice Cosmetics, Palladio, and THESAEM are all represented, spanning a range of formulas, shades, and price points from budget-friendly picks to high-end splurges.

Scroll down to see our top picks ranked by PF Score.

Award Product PF Score About PF ScoreThe PF Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more › Price
Best Overall Stila Color Correcting Palette 0.45 Oz Stila Color Correcting Palette 0.45 Oz 8.4/10 Buy
Editor's Pick Charlotte Tilbury Magic Vanish Color Corrector - Fair Charlotte Tilbury Magic Vanish Color Corrector - Fair 8.2/10 Buy
Best Value L.A. Girl Pro Conceal Set, 3-Pack Color Correctors L.A. Girl Pro Conceal Set, 3-Pack Color Correctors 8.1/10 Buy
Top Rated Bobbi Brown Skin Corrector Stick 0.11oz Bobbi Brown Skin Corrector Stick 0.11oz 8.0/10 Buy
Catrice Under Eye Brightener 020 Warm Nude Catrice Under Eye Brightener 020 Warm Nude 7.8/10 Buy
Palladio Under Eye Brightener, 0.15 oz Palladio Under Eye Brightener, 0.15 oz 7.3/10 Buy
Stila One Step Color Corrector & Brightening Primer Serum 1 Oz Stila One Step Color Corrector & Brightening Primer Serum 1 Oz 7.2/10 Buy
THESAEM Cover Perfection Triple Pot Concealer 03 THESAEM Cover Perfection Triple Pot Concealer 03 7.0/10 Buy
1
Stila Color Correcting Palette 0.45 Oz
Best Overall

Stila Color Correcting Palette 0.45 Oz

stila · 8.4/10 PF Score About PF ScoreThe PF Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more ›

An all-in-one cream and powder palette designed to neutralize redness, dark circles, sallowness, and grey tones across different skin tones. The formula blends vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants for long-wearing coverage that works best when layered with foundation and concealer.

Updated: Jul 23, 2026 About this updateLast updated on Jul 23, 2026 / Affiliate links, product images, titles, and pricing data may be provided through the Amazon Creators API, Impact Integrations, CJ API, Awin API, FlexOffers API, or similar tools from our affiliate partners. Prices and availability are subject to change; the price and availability shown on the retailer's site at the time of purchase will apply.

Pros

  • All-in-one format eliminates need for multiple correction products
  • Versatile for redness, dark circles, sallowness, and grey tones
  • Enriched with vitamins and antioxidants for skin benefits
  • Provides natural-looking coverage when applied correctly

Cons

  • Requires layering with foundation and concealer for best results, adding extra steps
  • No verified buyer reviews available to confirm real-world performance and shade range accuracy
  • Requires additional setting powder (yellow or lavender) for optimal color correction longevity
2
Charlotte Tilbury Magic Vanish Color Corrector - Fair
Editor's Pick

Charlotte Tilbury Magic Vanish Color Corrector - Fair

Charlotte Tilbury · 8.2/10 PF Score About PF ScoreThe PF Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more ›

A peach-toned color corrector designed to neutralize blue-undertoned dark circles under fair skin. Formulated with Vitamin E and mica for a luminous finish, it works best as a prep step before concealer.

Updated: Jul 23, 2026 About this updateLast updated on Jul 23, 2026 / Affiliate links, product images, titles, and pricing data may be provided through the Amazon Creators API, Impact Integrations, CJ API, Awin API, FlexOffers API, or similar tools from our affiliate partners. Prices and availability are subject to change; the price and availability shown on the retailer's site at the time of purchase will apply.

Pros

  • Peach tone effectively neutralizes cool-toned circles on fair skin
  • Lightweight, creamy formula blends smoothly without tugging
  • Nourishing ingredients support under-eye skin barrier health
  • Compact 0.08 oz size with precision application potential

Cons

  • Very small size means limited product per purchase
  • No verified buyer reviews available to assess real-world performance
  • Requires layering with additional concealer for full coverage, adding to routine steps
3
L.A. Girl Pro Conceal Set, 3-Pack Color Correctors
Best Value

L.A. Girl Pro Conceal Set, 3-Pack Color Correctors

L.A. Girl · 8.1/10 PF Score About PF ScoreThe PF Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more ›

A trio of color-correcting concealers designed to neutralize discoloration and dark circles with opaque, crease-resistant coverage. The lightweight, creamy formula works across multiple skin tones, though limited reviews make it harder to assess real-world performance.

Updated: Jul 23, 2026 About this updateLast updated on Jul 23, 2026 / Affiliate links, product images, titles, and pricing data may be provided through the Amazon Creators API, Impact Integrations, CJ API, Awin API, FlexOffers API, or similar tools from our affiliate partners. Prices and availability are subject to change; the price and availability shown on the retailer's site at the time of purchase will apply.

Pros

  • Complete color-correction set addresses multiple skin concerns in one purchase
  • Lightweight, creamy texture won't feel heavy around sensitive eye area
  • Long-wearing formula minimizes need for reapplication throughout the day
  • Designed to minimize fine lines while providing full coverage

Cons

  • No verified buyer reviews available, making it difficult to assess consistency and actual performance
  • 4.9 rating appears placeholder-level with zero reviews, limiting confidence in product reliability
  • Bundle format means you cannot customize which correctors you need
4
Bobbi Brown Skin Corrector Stick 0.11oz
Top Rated

Bobbi Brown Skin Corrector Stick 0.11oz

Bobbi Brown · 8.0/10 PF Score About PF ScoreThe PF Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more ›

A color-correcting stick designed to neutralize dark circles and under-eye discoloration with 12-hour hydration. The stick format applies smoothly without creasing, making it ideal for targeted concealer prep work.

Updated: Jul 23, 2026 About this updateLast updated on Jul 23, 2026 / Affiliate links, product images, titles, and pricing data may be provided through the Amazon Creators API, Impact Integrations, CJ API, Awin API, FlexOffers API, or similar tools from our affiliate partners. Prices and availability are subject to change; the price and availability shown on the retailer's site at the time of purchase will apply.

Pros

  • Non-creasing stick formula stays put through the day without settling or caking
  • 16 shade range accommodates various skin tones and discoloration types
  • Hydrating ingredients deliver plumper, smoother-looking results beyond basic coverage
  • Precise stick applicator allows targeted treatment of specific problem areas

Cons

  • No verified buyer reviews available to confirm real-world performance and longevity claims
  • Small 0.11oz size may require frequent reapplication or repurchasing for regular users
  • Premium price point typical for Bobbi Brown luxury beauty positioning
5
Catrice Under Eye Brightener 020 Warm Nude

Catrice Under Eye Brightener 020 Warm Nude

Catrice Cosmetics · 7.8/10 PF Score About PF ScoreThe PF Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more ›

A TikTok-trending color corrector designed to neutralize dark circles and under-eye shadows with a warm nude tone. Formulated with hyaluronic acid and shea butter, it offers medium coverage that blends naturally for a brightened, radiant look.

Updated: Jul 23, 2026 About this updateLast updated on Jul 23, 2026 / Affiliate links, product images, titles, and pricing data may be provided through the Amazon Creators API, Impact Integrations, CJ API, Awin API, FlexOffers API, or similar tools from our affiliate partners. Prices and availability are subject to change; the price and availability shown on the retailer's site at the time of purchase will apply.

Pros

  • Targeted color-correcting formula specifically designed for under-eye concerns
  • Clean ingredient list without parabens, fragrance, or microplastics
  • Caring formula with skin-nourishing hyaluronic acid and shea butter
  • Medium coverage allows for natural blending without heavy concealer feel

Cons

  • No verified buyer reviews available to assess real-world performance and longevity
  • Limited shade range (warm nude may not suit all skin tones)
  • Small 0.14 oz container requires frequent repurchasing for daily use
6
Palladio Under Eye Brightener, 0.15 oz

Palladio Under Eye Brightener, 0.15 oz

Palladio · 7.3/10 PF Score About PF ScoreThe PF Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more ›

A caffeine-infused under-eye concealer designed to minimize dark circles and puffiness with peptides and vitamin E. Works as both a color corrector and primer for light to medium skin tones, blending skincare benefits with medium coverage makeup.

Updated: Jul 23, 2026 About this updateLast updated on Jul 23, 2026 / Affiliate links, product images, titles, and pricing data may be provided through the Amazon Creators API, Impact Integrations, CJ API, Awin API, FlexOffers API, or similar tools from our affiliate partners. Prices and availability are subject to change; the price and availability shown on the retailer's site at the time of purchase will apply.

Pros

  • Combines skincare actives (caffeine, peptides, vitamin E) with color correction
  • Available in three shades to match different skin tones
  • Paraben-free and certified cruelty-free
  • Works as both concealer and primer in one product
  • Clean beauty formulation without harsh chemicals

Cons

  • No verified customer reviews available to assess real-world performance
  • Small 0.15 oz size may require frequent repurchasing
  • Limited to three shade options compared to competitors with broader shade ranges
7
Stila One Step Color Corrector & Brightening Primer Serum 1 Oz

Stila One Step Color Corrector & Brightening Primer Serum 1 Oz

stila · 7.2/10 PF Score About PF ScoreThe PF Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more ›

A multi-tasking primer serum with triple color-correcting pigments designed to even skin tone and neutralize redness, sallowness, and sunspots before makeup application. Oil-free and infused with a mineral complex of 15 vitamins and antioxidants for hydration and pore minimization.

Updated: Jul 23, 2026 About this updateLast updated on Jul 23, 2026 / Affiliate links, product images, titles, and pricing data may be provided through the Amazon Creators API, Impact Integrations, CJ API, Awin API, FlexOffers API, or similar tools from our affiliate partners. Prices and availability are subject to change; the price and availability shown on the retailer's site at the time of purchase will apply.

Pros

  • Innovative three-pigment formula addresses multiple skin tone concerns in one product
  • Hydrating base with mineral complex helps control oil and minimize pores
  • Oil-free and fragrance-free suitable for sensitive or acne-prone skin
  • Compact 1 oz size is convenient for travel and daily use

Cons

  • No verified customer reviews available to assess real-world performance and blending ease
  • Pea-sized application amount may require precise dispensing for optimal color correction coverage
  • Premium pricing typical of luxury beauty segment may limit accessibility
8
THESAEM Cover Perfection Triple Pot Concealer 03

THESAEM Cover Perfection Triple Pot Concealer 03

THESAEM · 7.0/10 PF Score About PF ScoreThe PF Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more ›

A three-shade Korean concealer palette designed for light skin tones, offering color correction for redness and dark circles in one compact pot. The balm texture includes sweet almond oil for nourishment, though it lacks verified buyer feedback to confirm real-world performance.

Updated: Jul 23, 2026 About this updateLast updated on Jul 23, 2026 / Affiliate links, product images, titles, and pricing data may be provided through the Amazon Creators API, Impact Integrations, CJ API, Awin API, FlexOffers API, or similar tools from our affiliate partners. Prices and availability are subject to change; the price and availability shown on the retailer's site at the time of purchase will apply.

Pros

  • Multi-functional palette eliminates need for separate concealers and color correctors
  • Nourishing formula with sweet almond oil helps prevent dryness during extended wear
  • Three distinct shades address different concerns: blemishes, redness, and bluish undertones
  • Balm texture provides buildable, blendable coverage
  • Comes with brush for precision application without additional purchase

Cons

  • No verified customer reviews available, so durability and blend performance remain unconfirmed
  • Limited to light skin tones only, with shade range 13-21
  • Balm-type formula may not suit oily skin types or warmer climates

Color Correctors Buying Guide

Choosing a color corrector is more nuanced than picking a shade you like the look of in the tube.

The formula type, finish, skin tone compatibility, and the specific concern you’re targeting all play a significant role in how effective the product will be in practice. The sections below break down every factor worth considering before you buy.

Matching Shade to Skin Concern

Color correction works on the principle of complementary colors: the hue you apply sits opposite your unwanted tone on the color wheel, effectively canceling it out. Green correctors neutralize redness caused by rosacea, acne, or general irritation.

Peach and salmon tones cancel the blue and purple discoloration typical of under-eye circles on fair to medium skin tones, while deeper orange shades are better suited to medium and dark complexions facing the same concern.

Yellow correctors address sallowness and minor bruising, and lavender counteracts yellow or sallow tones for very fair skin.

A common mistake is choosing a corrector that is too saturated or too light for your skin tone. On deeper skin, a peach corrector that works beautifully on a fair complexion may leave an ashy or unnatural cast.

Always match both the corrector shade and its intensity to your own skin depth.

Multi-pan palettes, like those offering orange, yellow, and green in one kit, give you the flexibility to mix and layer, which is particularly useful if your concerns vary across different areas of your face.

If you are also shopping for a complementary product, our guide to concealers covers the products best suited to layering over your corrector for a seamless finish.

Formula Type: Cream, Liquid, Stick, or Powder

Color correctors come in four main formulas, and the right one depends heavily on your skin type and how you prefer to apply makeup.

Cream formulas offer buildable, blendable coverage and are the most forgiving for beginners since they blend easily with a fingertip or damp sponge. They tend to work across most skin types but can emphasize texture on very oily complexions.

Liquid correctors are lighter and more wearable for daily use, often doubling as primers or serums with skincare benefits.

Stick formulas are portable and precise, making them ideal for targeted spot correction rather than all-over application. They suit drier skin particularly well since many are formulated with hydrating ingredients like vitamin E or plant-based oils.

Powder correctors offer the sheerest coverage and work best as a finishing step to set a cream corrector underneath, or on oilier skin types that need longer wear without slipping.

For skin that needs extra care under makeup, a serum-based corrector that also functions as a primer can meaningfully simplify your routine.

Coverage Level and Buildability

Not all color correctors are designed to deliver the same intensity of coverage. Some are highly pigmented, formulated to knock out severe discoloration in a single, thin layer.

Others are more sheer, intended to be layered or used as a primer beneath a full-coverage concealer.

Understanding which camp a product falls into helps you avoid the most common color corrector error: applying too much pigment, which results in a cakey, unnatural finish that is harder to blend out than the original discoloration.

A good rule of thumb is to start with the smallest amount possible, roughly the size of a grain of rice for targeted work, and build up only if needed.

Highly pigmented correctors, particularly those in palette form, are more efficient and often more economical in the long run because you use far less per application.

If your skin concerns are mild, a lighter, everyday corrector with a more skin-like finish may be all you need before applying a sheer foundation on top.

Skin Type Compatibility and Skincare Ingredients

Modern color correctors increasingly blur the line between makeup and skincare, incorporating actives like caffeine peptides, vitamin E, hyaluronic acid, and plant extracts that benefit the skin beneath the pigment.

For those with dry or mature skin, a corrector enriched with hydrating or plumping ingredients can prevent the product from settling into fine lines.

For oily or acne-prone skin, an oil-free, lightweight formula will wear more reliably throughout the day without migrating into creases.

It is also worth checking whether the corrector is non-comedogenic if you plan to use it near breakout-prone areas.

Some formulas marketed for dark circles also contain caffeine to temporarily de-puff and improve circulation, delivering a cosmetic and functional benefit simultaneously.

If you already use an active skincare routine, layering a skincare-infused corrector can streamline your morning routine without adding unnecessary steps.

Finish and Wearability

Woman applying makeup in natural light, examining finish and wearability in mirror
Photo by StockSnap

The finish of a color corrector matters both aesthetically and practically.

Correctors with a luminous or light-reflecting finish, often achieved through mica particles, are particularly effective under the eyes where a subtle glow can make the area appear more awake and lifted.

However, the same luminosity applied over redness on the nose or chin can draw attention rather than deflect it, so matching finish to the location of your concern is important.

Matte-finish correctors tend to stay in place longer and layer more cleanly under foundation or concealer, making them better suited to all-day wear.

Look for products that claim extended wear, ideally eight hours or more, if you need reliable performance throughout a full workday.

Wear time is especially relevant for cream and liquid formulas, which are more susceptible to oxidation and transfer than their powder counterparts.

Price Point and Value

Woman examining and comparing different makeup products on bathroom counter with natural lighting
Photo by brunamereu

Color correctors span an enormous price range, from single-digit drugstore options to luxury formulas from prestige brands.

Higher price does not always translate to better performance: some of the highest-rated options in this roundup are affordably priced and punch well above their cost.

That said, premium formulas often justify their price through more refined textures, broader shade ranges, and the inclusion of higher-quality skincare actives.

If you are new to color correcting, starting with an affordable multi-shade set or palette is a low-risk way to experiment with different corrector tones before committing to a pricier single product.

Conversely, if you have a very specific, persistent concern, investing in a corrector purpose-built for that issue and formulated for your skin type is likely to deliver better results than a general-purpose budget option.

Consider value in terms of the amount of product per application, since highly pigmented formulas often last significantly longer than sheer alternatives.

Why You Should Trust Us

ProductFind is an independent review publication. Every product in this guide was evaluated by our editorial team using a consistent, structured research framework.

We analyze published manufacturer specifications, synthesize expert review consensus from professional makeup artists, beauty editors, and dermatologists, and incorporate verified buyer feedback from confirmed purchasers across major retail platforms.

Each product is assigned a PF Score on a scale of 0 to 10, reflecting its overall performance across all evaluated criteria relative to its category.

We do not conduct our own product trials; our evaluations are grounded in research, published data, expert review consensus, and verified buyer feedback.

This approach allows us to evaluate a broad range of products systematically and without bias toward any particular brand or retailer. Our rankings are determined solely by PF Score and editorial assessment, not by commercial relationships.

ProductFind may earn an affiliate commission when you purchase through links in this article. This relationship does not influence our rankings, scores, or editorial recommendations in any way. We recommend only products that our research supports as genuinely strong performers in their category.

Final Thoughts

The market for color correctors is crowded, but the standout options in this roundup cover a broad enough range of skin tones, concerns, formulas, and price points that most shoppers will find an excellent match. Here are our top editorial picks by category:

  • Best Overall: Stila Color Correcting Palette, Correct And Perfect All In One earns the top PF Score in this roundup with its versatile cream-and-powder dual format, broad coverage across multiple skin concerns, and a formula that professional makeup artists consistently recommend for buildable, blendable results.
  • Best High-End Pick: Charlotte Tilbury Magic Vanish Color Corrector delivers a buttery, luminous cream formula enriched with mica for a visibly brightened complexion, earning strong marks from verified buyers for its ease of blending and efficacy on dark circles and puffiness.
  • Best Budget Set: L.A. Girl Pro Conceal Set offers exceptional value as a three-corrector bundle covering orange, yellow, and green tones, making it the most practical entry point for anyone new to color correcting or building a multi-shade kit on a limited budget.
  • Best Stick Formula: Bobbi Brown Skin Corrector Stick stands out for its portable, precise application format, hydrating coffee seed extract and vitamin E formula, and an impressive 12-hour wear claim validated by consistent positive feedback from buyers with dry and mature skin types.
  • Best Drugstore Under-Eye Option: Catrice Under Eye Brightener punches significantly above its accessible price point, offering a warm nude shade formulated specifically for dark circle correction that buyers routinely describe as genuinely effective and easy to blend into a wide range of light to medium skin tones.

Whichever option you choose, remember that color correcting works best as a targeted step, not an all-over application. A little product in the right shade goes a long way toward a cleaner, more natural finish under your regular foundation or concealer routine.

Frequently Asked Questions

What color corrector should I use for dark circles?

The right corrector shade for dark circles depends on your skin tone. Fair to medium complexions typically benefit most from peach or salmon correctors, which neutralize the blue and purple undertones common in under-eye discoloration.

Medium to deep skin tones often need a richer orange corrector to effectively counteract the same tones.

Applying a thin layer of corrector before your concealer or foundation dramatically reduces the amount of product needed for full coverage and prevents a cakey result.

Do color correctors go on before or after foundation?

Color correctors are applied before foundation and concealer, directly onto clean, moisturized skin or over a primer. The corrector neutralizes the unwanted tone first, then foundation and concealer are layered on top to unify the complexion.

Applying them in this order means you need significantly less coverage product overall, which contributes to a lighter, more natural-looking finish.

Set cream correctors with a light dusting of translucent powder before foundation to prevent them from moving or mixing with the product above.

Can I use a color corrector without foundation on top?

In most cases, color correctors are not designed to be worn alone as a finished look since they are formulated to be visible enough to neutralize discoloration rather than blend seamlessly into skin.

However, some sheer, skin-tinted correctors, particularly those designed as skincare-makeup hybrids, can be worn with minimal or no product on top for a light, everyday effect.

For most targeted correctors, layering at least a sheer concealer or tinted moisturizer over the top will give you a polished, blended result.

How is color correcting different from using concealer?

Concealers are formulated to match or slightly brighten your skin tone, adding coverage that blends into the surrounding area.

They work well for minor discoloration but can struggle with more intense pigmentation like deep dark circles or pronounced redness because they are competing with the underlying tone rather than neutralizing it.

Color correctors work upstream of that process, canceling the problematic pigment so that a smaller, more natural amount of concealer or foundation achieves complete coverage. Think of a color corrector as prep work that makes your concealer significantly more effective.

For a closer look at how the two categories work together, our roundup of concealers for every skin type covers the best complementary products in detail.

Are color correctors suitable for sensitive or acne-prone skin?

Many color correctors are formulated to be gentle enough for sensitive skin, but the safest choices are those labeled oil-free and non-comedogenic, particularly if you plan to apply them over active breakouts.

Cream formulas with heavy oils or waxes can potentially clog pores if used repeatedly over acne-prone areas, so lighter liquid or water-based options are generally the better choice for these skin types.

Always check the ingredient list for common irritants like fragrance or alcohol if your skin is prone to reactivity.

How do I apply a color corrector so it doesn’t look patchy?

The key to a seamless application is using minimal product and blending immediately.

Apply the smallest amount possible to the target area, then blend outward using a damp makeup sponge, a soft synthetic brush, or a fingertip warmed by the heat of your hand.

Tapping rather than dragging motions tend to preserve coverage while preventing streaking.

If the formula looks too intense after blending, do not add more product to cover it: instead, layer a sheer foundation or concealer on top, which will diffuse the corrector tone while maintaining the neutralizing effect underneath.

About the author

Isaiah Butler
Isaiah Butler

Isaiah is a reviewer and writer for ProductFind who specializes in Makeup. Isaiah evaluates products through independent research: specifications, expert review consensus, and verified buyer feedback, and rates each one on the PF Score. Isaiah focuses on helping readers pick the right makeup for their needs and budget.